Skip to main content

Verdict

Winner: YNAB

For users who want a structured budgeting methodology that changes spending habits

YNAB is better for users committed to zero-based budgeting and debt payoff. Simplifi is better for casual budgeters who want simple spending tracking at less than half the price. YNAB changes behavior; Simplifi tracks it.

Try YNAB Free

34-day free trial · No credit card required

TL;DR

Winner: YNAB

Best for: Serious budgeters who want zero-based methodology and shared household access

$51.12/yr more (YNAB $99 vs Simplifi $47.88)

YNAB vs Simplifi (2026): Which Is Better?

Published Jan 15, 2026 · 8 min read

Pricing verified Feb 23, 2026

We compared YNAB and Simplifi by Quicken on pricing, methodology, and ease of use. YNAB wins for serious budgeters — here's why, and when Simplifi's simplicity is worth the savings.

Try YNAB ← This is an affiliate link — we may earn a commission.

Feature-by-feature

Winner

YNAB

$8.25/mo billed annually

  • Bank Syncing
  • Investment Tracking
  • Net Worth Dashboard
  • Bill Tracking
  • Shared Household Access
  • Custom Categories
  • Recurring Transactions
  • Goal Tracking
  • Credit Score Monitoring
  • Subscription Tracking
  • Zero-Based Budgeting
  • Envelope Budgeting
  • CSV Import
  • Mobile App
  • Web App
  • Reports & Charts
  • Custom Rules
  • Crypto Tracking
  • Learning Center
  • Negotiation Service

Simplifi by Quicken

$3.99/mo billed annually

  • Bank Syncing
  • Investment Tracking
  • Net Worth Dashboard
  • Bill Tracking
  • Shared Household Access
  • Custom Categories
  • Recurring Transactions
  • Goal Tracking
  • Credit Score Monitoring
  • Subscription Tracking
  • Zero-Based Budgeting
  • Envelope Budgeting
  • CSV Import
  • Mobile App
  • Web App
  • Reports & Charts
  • Custom Rules
  • Crypto Tracking
  • Learning Center
  • Negotiation Service

Pricing breakdown

How much does each app really cost?

Our pick

YNAB

Monthly $14.99/mo
Annual (per month) $8.25/mo
Annual total $99/yr
Free trial 34 days
Try YNAB Free

34-day free trial · No credit card required

Simplifi by Quicken

Monthly $5.99/mo
Annual (per month) $3.99/mo
Annual total $47.88/yr
Free trial 30 days

Best fit

Winner

Who should choose YNAB

  • Debt-focused users who need enforced spending limits and a methodology that prevents overspending
  • Couples who want shared access to the same budgets, categories, and goals in one account
  • Learners who benefit from YNAB's 34-day trial, structured workshops, and 100K+ member community

Who should choose Simplifi by Quicken

  • Budget-conscious users who want solid spending tracking at $3.99/mo — less than half of YNAB's price
  • Casual budgeters who want to see where money goes without committing to a strict methodology
  • Quicken users who want a modern cloud app from a company with 40+ years of financial software experience

Switching from Mint?

YNAB

YNAB supports CSV import and has a Mint migration guide. You'll rebuild categories and budget targets from scratch — YNAB's system is fundamentally different.

CSV import

Simplifi by Quicken

Simplifi does not support CSV import. It syncs via Plaid from your connection date. Historical data won't transfer.

The bottom line

Our final recommendation

YNAB is better for users committed to zero-based budgeting and debt payoff. Simplifi is better for casual budgeters who want simple spending tracking at less than half the price. YNAB changes behavior; Simplifi tracks it.

Try YNAB Free

34-day free trial · No credit card required

Frequently Asked Questions

Is YNAB better than Simplifi?

For serious budgeters, yes. YNAB's zero-based methodology forces intentional spending and has helped users save an average of $600 in the first two months. Simplifi is a simpler, cheaper alternative for users who just want to track spending without a strict system.

How much does YNAB cost compared to Simplifi?

YNAB costs $14.99/mo or $99/yr. Simplifi costs $5.99/mo or $47.88/yr ($3.99/mo billed annually). Simplifi is $51.12/yr cheaper — more than half the savings on annual plans.

Does Simplifi have envelope budgeting?

No. Simplifi uses traditional category-based spending tracking with spending plans. It doesn't enforce zero-based budgeting or envelope categories. If you want every dollar assigned a purpose, YNAB is the right choice.

Which app is easier to learn?

Simplifi is significantly easier to learn. It requires minimal setup — connect accounts and start tracking. YNAB has the steepest learning curve of any budgeting app because it requires understanding its four-rule methodology.

Does YNAB track investments?

No. YNAB focuses exclusively on budgeting and cash flow. It does not track investment portfolios, asset allocation, or performance. Simplifi includes basic investment account tracking and net worth calculations.

Can I share either app with my partner?

YNAB supports shared household access on all plans. Simplifi does not support shared accounts — each user needs their own subscription.

Which app has a better free trial?

YNAB offers a 34-day free trial. Simplifi offers a 30-day free trial. Both give you enough time to evaluate the full feature set before committing.

Is Simplifi good for beginners?

Yes. Simplifi is one of the most beginner-friendly budgeting apps. It requires minimal setup, has clean reports, and doesn't force a specific methodology. YNAB is better for beginners who want to learn disciplined budgeting from scratch.

Which app helps save more money?

YNAB users report saving an average of $600 in the first two months through intentional budgeting. Simplifi helps you see where money goes but doesn't enforce spending limits. YNAB changes behavior; Simplifi tracks it.

Get the verdict delivered

Pricing updates, new comparisons, and the occasional budgeting tip — all in under 2 minutes.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.